- For other uses, see Episode 5.
The boys have found and recruited Saskia as their new water element and perform the tracking spell. However it backfires, and Jake begins to turn to stone. Felix believes the reason the water in the spell did not show Andy's whereabouts is because he's in the other universe, where Ellen liked him and he was popular. Meanwhile, Jake's condition worsens and he's forced to tell Felix and Sam. They consult Nai Nai, who informs them he got an earth overdose during the spell. They realise that Saskia is an Earth Element, and she had been the additional earth that was disrupting the spell. After the boys discover that Ellen is the missing water element, Felix is able to cure Jake and they tell her the truth about everything. The boys and Ellen then cast the Unmaking Spell to take them back to the other universe to get Andy.
|Dougie Baldwin||Felix Ferne|
|Rahart Adams||Sam Conte|
|Matt Testro||Jake Riles|
|Joel Lok||Andy Lau (credited only)|
|Michala Banas||Phoebe Hartley|
|Victoria Thaine||Alice Hartley|
|Darci McDonald||Ellen O'Donnell|
|Phoebe Roberts||Saskia Bloom|
|Sean Rees-Wemyss||Oscar Ferne|
|Nicholas Coughlan||Mr. Bates|
|Jim Russell||Detective Roland Murphy|
|Heidi Arena||Cathy Ferne|
|Michelle Gerster||Viv Lau|
|Sam Sharwood||Mike Parker|
|Logan Phillips||Trent Long|
- The boys mention how Nai Nai was able to cure Jake last time he was sick.