The episode begins with Jake and Sam reminiscing on how they lost the Book of Shadows to Alice, along with any hope of getting Andy back. However Felix comes up with the idea of finding a new element, which would allow them to perform a Tracking Spell to find Andy. Sam and Jake are surprised at the possibility of there being another water element, leading Felix to explain that they aren't the only individuals with magical potential. Their discussion is cut short when they see Roland parked outside Felix's house.
Later, the Nowhere Boys decide to search for a new water element at Bremin High School. Felix explains how he managed to track down the four current members of the Nowhere Boys, where he spotted individuals with signs of magic potential. For Jake, Felix had been spying on him and his friends during a daily bullying ritual towards Mike Parker. Mike had hid in a dumpster, but Jake was somehow able to find Mike, before stealing his lunch. For Sam, Felix once spotted him flirting with Mia, where Sam was somehow able to keep a student from walking into a door when his back was turned. For Andy, Felix noticed Andy was able to give the correct answer in class before Bates had even said the question. After determining their magical potential, Felix had figured out each other boys' elements based on their personalities, as shown by the notes in his diary.
|Dougie Baldwin||Felix Ferne|
|Rahart Adams||Sam Conte|
|Matt Testro||Jake Riles|
|Joel Lok||Andy Lau (credited only)|
|Michala Banas||Phoebe Hartley|
|Victoria Thaine||Alice Hartley|
|Darci McDonald||Ellen O'Donnell|
|Sean Rees-Wemyss||Oscar Ferne|
|Nicholas Coughlan||Mr. Bates|
|Jim Russell||Detective Roland Murphy|
|Heidi Arena||Cathy Ferne|
|Michelle Gerster||Viv Lau|
|Logan Phillips||Trent Long|
|Phoebe Roberts||Saskia Bloom|
- The boys star-signs are revealed in this episode, via Felix's Book of Shadows.
- Sam is a Libra, Jake is a Taurus, and Andy is a Pisces.
- This is the first time in Season 2 to where someone is revealed to have magical potential, in this case Saskia.
- In the entry for Sam in his diary, Felix had written "He's an airhead!" and "try to find alternate! So dumb", once again showing Felix's opinion on how stupid Sam is.
- Jake's coldness to Bates and declaring he is nothing more than his teacher, is a callback to how Bates and Jake's mother were together in the Alternate World.